SCOPE
is a process of discovery, assimilation of information, creativity,
and learning by doing. Through an interactive software interface
SCOPE allows people to design, implement, and evaluate effective
health communication projects directly on the computer. SCOPEs
substantial database provides the groundwork on which to establish
a communication strategy. As SCOPE users interpret information
and use it to design their projects, they acquire a practical
appreciation of the magnitude and complexity of health communication
challenges. The SCOPE experience encourages health communicators
to:
- Appreciate
carefully analyzed data as the scientific basis for planning.
- Acquire
a multi-stage approach to communication planning that takes
into account the audience, resources, and state of health
communication activities in a given region.
- Achieve
a sense of empowerment in using computer simulation and
other research and management tools.
- Understand
how these tools can identify and analyze cost-effective
communication interventions before trying to implement them
on a large scale in the field.
How
SCOPE Evolved
We started development of SCOPE in 1992 as a workshop training
exercise. The goal was to find a more useful tool to teach participants
in "Advances
in Health Communication and Advocacy" workshops (in
Baltimore as well as in our project countries abroad) how to
apply specific methods and frameworks to overall health planning.
The paper and pencil exercise that workshop facilitators had
been using prior to SCOPE had relied on a fictitious country
and data to teach strategy development. Moving the exercise
to a computer had three major advantages:
- The
computer could store a great deal of quantitative and qualitative
data along with descriptive graphics, concepts, and photos.
- Since
these materials could be easily accessed, the strategy development
exercise could use real data already available from an actual
country project.
- Access
to colorful photobanks and illustrations could stimulate
participants to design creative activities and storyboards.
Thus the computerized strategy development exercise became
a more powerful, more immediate experience to participants:
SCOPE was based on reality based and it was comprehensive
in scope, rich in data and illustrations, colorful, and
fun to use - even for computer novices.
Since its initial development, we have been testing and using
SCOPE to train health professionals in the United States and
overseas. The first version of SCOPE was developed using data,
graphs, and visuals from Turkey. By 1995, JHU/CCP had responded
to increasing requests to develop special country versions.
SCOPE country versions are now available for Bangladesh, Egypt,
Ghana, Kenya, India (Uttar Pradesh), Indonesia, Nepal, Nigeria,
Peru, Philippines, Tanzania, Turkey, Zambia, and Zimbabwe. Some
versions have been translated into French, Spanish, and Arabic.
The Concept of Teamwork and Participation
JHU/PCS
designed SCOPE to reinforce the key concepts of the "Advances
in Health Communication and Advocacy" workshop. Advances
workshops are held in Baltimore at least once a year for four
weeks for high-level decision makers worldwide. Advances workshops
are also held in Africa, Asia, Latin America, and the Near East.
The
SCOPE exercise groups workshop participants in teams of three
to a computer. Each team acts as a unit of the Ministry of Health
and is entrusted with designing a comprehensive strategy for
a family planning project. Each team has a budget of US $1 million
to design an 18-month project. Every decision the team makes
is automatically recorded and calculated on a budget table that
shows allocated, actual, and final balance.
A
core concept of Advances workshops is the acronym TEAM (Together
Everyone Achieves More). The SCOPE teams are intended
to foster a spirit of teamwork. The teams simulate situations
that participants face in their work when they leave the workshop
- dealing with different personalities, beliefs, goals, attitudes,
styles. When team members work well together they create effective
strategies. When teamwork is lacking, their strategies suffer.
SCOPE requires team members to agree on decisions before they
can proceed to the next stage of strategy development. Team
members may even have to deal with persuasive or domineering
co-team members, or accept someone elses idea over their
own. The bottom line is they will have to find solutions to
disagreements - just as in real life strategy planning situations.
SCOPE
teams exemplify the participatory approach to training. Team
members spend a great deal of their time discussing and working
out ideas among themselves. In fact, in a highly participatory
workshop in Bangladesh, participants surprised workshops co-sponsors
by rating the SCOPE exercise as the workshops most participatory
session.
SCOPE
Framework Based on P-Process
The
framework of Advances workshops is the P-Process,
JHU/CCPs planning model. The P-Process is also the framework
for SCOPE. SCOPE architecture runs parallel to the workshops
progression. SCOPE first introduces participants to the key
concepts of strategy development (i.e., hierarchy of effects,
the multi-stage approach to planning, and the concept of strategic
leverage) and then delves into the five steps of the P-Process:
Analysis, Design, Development, Implementation & Evaluation,
and Review.
High
Ratings for SCOPE
Workshop
participants rate SCOPE highly. It is very popular and effective
even among participants with no previous computer experience.
For example, participants in a recent "Advances" workshop
in Zambia gave SCOPE a 9.24 on a ten point scale. In the words
of SCOPE participants:
- "The
SCOPE exercise is a life-like simulation of the big real
world of campaign planning and taught us the imperative
of focusing on pretesting and evaluation before going ahead."
- "No
amount of lecturing can give participants the kind of experience
one goes through when using SCOPE."
- "SCOPE
forces you to think critically, allowing the user to continually
review for consistency and coherence."
- "It
was a great learning and working experience. Immediate feedback.
Strengthened self-confidence."
The Future of SCOPE
To enhance the usefulness of SCOPE for training and for planning
actual health communication programs, JHU/CCP continuously develops
and upgrades the program. The current goals are to:
- Improve
SCOPE architecture and production procedures which will
reduce the cost and time of producing and updating country
versions;
- Develop
and enhance SCOPE features that will be greatly valued by
public health planners and managers. This implies bringing
SCOPE closer to a performance support system that provides
on-the-job access to integrated information, advice and
learning experiences.
To
achieve these two goals, JHU/PCS is pursuing the following strategies:
- The
integration of the "P"-Process framework with
country-specific data sources: The "P-Process framework
provides a generic process for any country developing health
programs. Integrating that process, as it is depicted in
SCOPE, with dynamic, country-specific sources of health
data will provide a powerful tool for the health professional.
Such a tool would provide program support in such areas
as: data analysis, planning, monitoring, and evaluation.
An
example is the "Trends and Benchmarks" frame
which has already been integrated into the Analysis stage of
SCOPE. The SCOPE "Trends and Benchmarks" frame reads,
among others, modified World Bank databases. SCOPE turns the
raw, on-the-spot data into easily readable graphs and charts
that can be revised as databases are updated.
- Making
the Impossible Possible: JHU/PCS is developing SCOPE features
that make "impossible tasks" possible. This approach
means taking advantage of what computers do best, i.e.,
fast retrieval, processing and graphic presentation of data.
An
example is the "Geographical Mapping" feature,
which has been incorporated into the Bangladesh, Indonesia,
Kenya, Nigeria, Philippines, and Zambia versions of SCOPE. SCOPE
displays color-coded maps of districts, provinces or states.
The colors show changes in health indicators or progress or
impact of health communication programs. When SCOPE users click
on a particular region, they can identify a variety of variables
specific to that region, ie., contraceptive prevalence, maternal
mortality, literacy and educational levels. Using a geographical
approach helps the user to identify patterns between health
indicators, and subsequently plan a program utilizing such information.
SCOPE continues to expand its parameters. A specific AIDS version
of SCOPE has been prepared for the Zimbabwe AIDS program (complete
with HIV animation!). A health program in Morocco has requested
a maternal and child health version for use by management staff.
A version of SCOPE that focuses on youth-related health issues
has been prepared for fall 97. In the meantime, we are
also preparing to release versions of SCOPE in Zambia and in
Bangladesh that are designed to be updated by the user, and
so have expanded use outside of a workshop setting.
Some
of the indicators used in SCOPE are as follows:
Total
Fertility Rate
Population, Total
Age Dependency Ratio
Population Growth, Annual%
Urban population (% of population)
Urban Population Growth Rate, Annual%
Population density (population per sq km)
Total Labor Force
Upper poverty line (local currency)
Labor Force in Agriculture %
Labor force in industry (% of total)
Female Labor Force %
Household income share, top 20% (% of income)
Household income share, bot 40% (% of income)
Household income share, bot 20% (% of income)
Food Expenditure, All (% OF GDP)
Food production per capita (1987=100)
Lower Poverty Line
GNP Per Capita
Consumer Price Index
Gross enroll. ratio, sec, tot (% schl age pop)
Gross enroll. ratio, sec, fem (% schl age pop)
Pupil-teacher ratio, primary
Pupil-teacher ratio, secondary
Pupils Reaching Grade 4
Illiteracy Rate Total
Illiteracy rate, female (% of females age 15+)
Newspaper circulation (per thousand population)
Gross enroll. ratio, prim, tot (% schl age pop)
Gross enroll. ratio, prim, mal (% schl age pop)
Gross enroll. ratio, prim, fem (% schl age pop)
Life expectancy at birth, fem advantage (years)
Maternal mortal. rate (per 100,000 live births)
Access to safe water, total (% of population)
Access to safe water, urban (% of population)
Access to safe water, rural (% of population)
Access to health care (% of population)
Population per Physician
Population per nurse
Population per hospital bed
Oral rehydration therapy, under 5 (% of cases)
Pub. expend., basic social services (% of GDP)
Infant mortality rate (per thous. live births)
Under 5 mortality rate (per thous. live births)
Presentations
involving SCOPE
SCOPE
- Strategic Communication Planning & Evaluation (In Population
Software Notes), V. 8-9, July, 1998.
Training
Division, JHU-CCP: SEDE symposium, Johns Hopkins University,
Baltimore MD, 1996.
Training
Division, JHU-CCP: SEDE symposium, Johns Hopkins University,
Baltimore MD, 1997.
Bailey,
Michael and Lozare, Benjamin: Prevention 97, Atlanta GA,
1997
Lozare,
B.; Bailey, M.; Wilcox, C. and Khan, O.: American Public
Health Association, Indianapolis IN, 1997
Bailey,
Michael and Khan, Omar: Population Association of America, Chicago
IL, 1998
Bailey,
Michael: International Health Geographics Conference, Baltimore
MD, 1998
TOP
| HOME
111
Market Place, Suite 310, Baltimore, MD 21202, USA
Phone: (410) 659.6300/Fax: (410) 659.6266/E-mail: webadmin@jhuccp.org